Describe the broad expression category (value / reference /
initializing) in the semantics IR textual format. This is redundant
information that can be calculated from the text that's already in the
output, but seems useful for understanding the structure of the IR.
Switch from a fully lowering-oriented approach to initializing
expressions in semantics IR to an approach that retains more information
about the high-level semantics of the program. Specifically:
- Always form an `Assign` node for a variable initialization or
assignment, even for empty types and when the actual initialization is
performed in-place by evaluating the right-hand side.
- Always form a `ReturnExpression` node for a return statement with an
expression, even when the actual initialization is performed in-place
into the return slot and the function doesn't return a value.
This is intended to permit us to more easily write semantic checks over
the IR, and to preserve a use edge from the use of an initializing
expression and its initializer in all cases.
To better support this, `MaterializeTemporary` is also split into two
nodes:
- A `TemporaryStorage` node allocates and provides the storage for a
temporary, and is emitted prior to emitting the initialization of the
temporary.
- A `Temporary` node connects the temporary storage to the initializer,
and is emitted after emitting the initialization.
Example testcase:
```carbon
fn F() -> (i32, i32);
fn G() -> (i32, i32) {
var v: (i32, i32) = F();
v = F();
return F();
}
fn H() -> i32 {
return G()[0];
}
```
Before:
```carbon-semir
fn @G() -> %return: (i32, i32) {
// ...
%v: (i32, i32) = var "v"
%.loc4_24: (i32, i32) = call @F() to %v
%.loc5: (i32, i32) = call @F() to %v
%.loc6: (i32, i32) = call @F() to %return
return
}
fn @H() -> i32 {
!entry:
%.loc10_11.1: (i32, i32) = materialize_temporary
%.loc10_11.2: (i32, i32) = call @G() to %.loc10_11.1
%.loc10_14: i32 = int_literal 0
%.loc10_15.1: i32 = tuple_index %.loc10_11.1, %.loc10_14
%.loc10_15.2: i32 = bind_value %.loc10_15.1
return %.loc10_15.2
}
```
After:
```carbon-semir
fn @G() -> %return: (i32, i32) {
// ...
%v: (i32, i32) = var "v"
%.loc4_24: (i32, i32) = call @F() to %v
assign %v, %.loc4_24
%.loc5: (i32, i32) = call @F() to %v
assign %v, %.loc5
%.loc6: (i32, i32) = call @F() to %return
return %.loc6
}
fn @H() -> i32 {
!entry:
%.loc10_11.1: (i32, i32) = temporary_storage
%.loc10_11.2: (i32, i32) = call @G() to %.loc10_11.1
%.loc10_14: i32 = int_literal 0
%.loc10_11.3: (i32, i32) = temporary %.loc10_11.1, %.loc10_11.2
%.loc10_15.1: i32 = tuple_index %.loc10_11.3, %.loc10_14
%.loc10_15.2: i32 = bind_value %.loc10_15.1
return %.loc10_15.2
}
```
Note that in the "Before" code, there is no indication in `G()` that we
assigned to `v`, and no path through "use" edges from the tuple indexing
in `H()` to the call to `G()`.
This change results in our not performing `memcpy`s into the destination
for tuple and struct initializers. This is a consequence of those
initializers not yet performing in-place initialization, and will be
fixed in a subsequent change.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Start treating function calls as initializing expressions instead of as
value expressions.
This required adding support for expression categories. Value bindings
and temporary materialization conversions are created where necessary to
transition between expression categories. For a function call with a
return slot, we speculatively create a materialized temporary before the
call and either commit to it or replace it with something else later,
once we see how the function call expression is actually used.
This change follows the direction suggested in #3133 for initializing
expressions: depending on the return type of a function, the return
value will either be initialized in-place or returned directly. This is
visible in the semantics IR, which is a little unfortunate but is
probably necessary as this is part of the semantics of the program.
---------
Co-authored-by: Chandler Carruth <chandlerc@gmail.com>
Previously, IR generated for the computation of the return type ended up
in the package's node block. Put it with the IR for the parameters for
consistency and cleanliness.
This removes BindName, putting name information directly on VarStorage.
As a side-effect of updating semantics_ir_test for this change, I also
noted that function bodies were being generated as invalid YAML so am
fixing that (just `{}` to `[]` bracketing, otherwise the test wouldn't
work anymore).
Because names are now available, I've updated lowering to use them for
vars.
In the SemIR formatter, the name is now repeated because it's a
parameter to VarStorage. I believe this is just default behavior, and
we'd have to special-case VarStorage to remove it because it's automatic
argument printing in action. On the balance, it felt like letting it
print was reasonable.
I've noted in places that the name on VarStorage is expected to be
optional, but am not adding support because I'd have no way of testing
it at present.