Files
carbon-lang/toolchain
Jon Ross-Perkins 4cb61ae4e1 Remove ArgKinds to encourage safer coding patterns (#5212)
#5171 ran into an issue where the wrong kind was associated with an arg
(`auto arg1 = RefineOperand(context, loc_id, arg0_kind,
action.arg1());`). This PR is trying to reduce risk of similar errors by
replaced `ArgKinds()` with instead an `ArgAndKind` structure and
corresponding accessors.

A couple things I considered and discarded were:

- Adding `CARBON_KIND_SWITCH` support (in this PR -- see #5216).
- The particular way that `ForCase` works would need to change, and I
was hesitant to do that here.
- But this is why I did add `As` to `ArgAndKind`, because it had me
thinking in that direction.
- Trying to make wrapper functions like `MutateArgs(callback_fn);`. This
kind of approach gets a little messy due to some of the conditional
passes, and in particular the reverse-iteration done for `PopOperand` in
subst.cpp
- Making something like `args_and_kinds() -> std::array<ArgAndKind, 2>`.
There's one spot where iteration is already set up as a loop, but for
others it felt a little convoluted with less gain than
`MutateArgs`-style things.

I'm not sure if there's a better way to set up the table generators, I
might keep tinkering with those for ideas.
2025-03-28 23:24:36 +00:00
..
2025-03-07 19:34:31 +00:00