This starts propagating is_extern on import, and warns when merging an
imported non-extern declaration with a local non-extern declaration.
Note this doesn't address import conflicts yet (i.e., two libraries
define an equivalent name) because they don't call merge logic.
On merge, I'm only setting values when new_is_definition because I think
it better matches the comment and resulting behavior. Note I now set
them even for bad redefinitions; I think this matches the comment, and
there's not a perfect choice here. I could change the flow back if
preferred.
Note this puts a spotlight on invalid nodes on imported decls, which I
think I'm going to need to address now. This isn't addressed by
ImportRef logic directly because the Function's decl_id is a
FunctionDecl, rather than the ImportRef that led to it. While I could
add the ImportRef link to each decl, I think adjusting the associated
NodeId is a better approach.
Still needs more merge/redeclaration logic for import semantics, but
this felt like a reasonable point to send a PR.
---------
Co-authored-by: Chandler Carruth <chandlerc@gmail.com>
Previously we used the default inst block formatting, which writes out a
parenthesized list of references, which would always be 'unexpected
instref's because nothing else prints the instructions in the decl
block.
In addition, track the decl block for function declarations like we do
for other kinds of declaration. This means that the parameter
declarations for a function are now properly rendered into the formatted
IR. Note that this adds a lot of verbosity to `function_decl`, but it
does accurately reflect the IR, and we'll probably want this information
to be printed once we start supporting more complex generic function
declarations.
This removes almost all the 'unexpected instref's in our formatted
output. There are remaining cases when a declarative scope contains
multiple blocks, where we only track one of those blocks. That happens
when there is control flow within declarative scopes, and for error
recovery when a class or interface or similar is defined more than once.
As requested in #3730.
I believe this PR is sufficient to pull in all current class features,
including the current bits of inheritance which have been implemented.
Because a class declaration can reference its own type, this creates an
incomplete type prior to constant loading.
Right now, the object representation is imported proactively, but
individual fields are left as ImportRefUnused. This means that member
functions and similar will only be imported if called.
This also adjusts how function parameters are being handled, to match
the expectations of Self param structure.
When formatting, I'm starting to look into constants. Otherwise we get
"unexpected instref".
Overall, there are a few things that may be worth further discussion:
- The lack of a constant corresponding to the ClassType on ClassDecl is
inconvenient -- I'd like to see how zygoloid feels about trying to
restructure this. i.e., I'm setting a constant in order to be able to
track things down later, it'd be nice if the normal IR did this simply
for consistency, or if we were able to combine these rather than having
separate instructions.
- Should we shift the parse node tracking further, and go with a setup
wherein imports can embed import references into that? e.g., negative
values go to another array which includes a ImportIRId for printing
diagnostics, replacing the invalid NodeId.
- Can the formatter switch to a more general scan of instructions for
naming, to eliminate the ImportRef constant approach added here?
- GetExprValueForLookupResult special-casing instructions felt
surprising, I might see if there's a way to restructure to avoid that.
But I think these issues are things that can be separated out.
This works by creating a faux FunctionDecl in the context of the current
IR, which seems to be working for function calls. Deduced params are
there, but won't really be tested until classes are up and running. Also
I may need to look further at return_slot_id to ensure it's working. But
the basics, I think, are here.
Reorganizes some other ImportRef work from `has_unresolved` that'd
relied on manual calls to a more detection-based `HasUnresolved`
approach that doesn't require as much checking.
This is a bit of a cleanup; I probably should've just renamed CrossRef
instead of adding ImportRefUsed.
Adding `is_builtin` to InstId is more about providing a standard API for
the check, which I expect to add a little more of.
Shifts import tests to validate that the BuildValueRepr CHECK isn't
accidentally hit.
This makes some changes to the formatter so that ImportRefUnused and
ImportRefUsed will both be labeled as "import_ref" with an "unused ->
used" argument change in textual IR, but is otherwise not changing
logic.
I'd excluded these initially just because I was thinking towards copies,
but under the current model I'm trying to catch all the decl types just
for consistency. Note references will still be a TODO error
(LazyImportRef is already tested for this, it just didn't feel necessary
to add individual tests while I try to sort out behavior).
Fixes an oversight where declarations in an entity's scope were being
added to the list of exports.
Note I'm trimming some Import API arguments as now-unused.
Jon Ross-Perkins
Richard Smith