We allow impl lookup to use `Self` which is partially identified, but we
were only allowing this for the `Self` facet appearing in the impl
lookup query self. We should also allow it when `Self` appears in the
impl lookup query target facet type.
But demonstrate that `Self` appearing in the interface of an
ImplWitnessAccess (a compound member access) is not sufficient at this
time, as it does not put `Self` into the type structure.
The `.Self` needs to be canonicalized when recording the witness, since
it will be a FacetAccessType in the `impls` clause.
Todo tests are also added for `C impls Y(.Self)`. The `.Self` in the
interface specific breaks everything as we end up replacing the `.Self`
with `C` in later `C as Y(.Self)` lookups, which then does not find the
witness.
Pull all the witnesses from `impls` constraints so that we capture
witnesses coming from named constraints on different self types, as `C
impls N(.Self)` may give witnesses for `C` or for other self types.
If a facet type contains `.X impls Y` then later references to `.X`
should know that it impls `Y`. This is done through a stack on the
context like for rewrites, where impl lookup can find constraints from
the current `where` expression being checked.
Similarly, if a facet type contains `.X impls (Y where .Z = T)`, then
`.X.(Y.Z) = T` should be available to later constraints in the facet
type for early application of rewrite rules. We add these rewrites to
the rewrite stack when handling the `impls` constraint
A nested designator like `.(X.X1).(Y.Y1)` results in nested
ImplWitnessAccess instructions, which can produce cycles in the
toolchain easily when replacing `.Self`.
First, when constructing a facet type like `V:! Z where .Z1 impls (Y
where .Y1 = U)` we substitute replace `.Self` in the nested facet type,
and in this case we replace `.Self` with `.Z1` which contains a `.Self`
of its own. This was coming from us being lazy about replacing `.Self`
in an `impl as` declaration, such as `impl C as Z where .Z1 = .Self`.
The self type is known there, so we can more eagerly replace `.Self` as
we do in a `require impls` declaration. Then the replacement for `.Self`
never comes with a `.Self` that needs to also be replaced. Any resulting
`.Self` would always be the top-level one.
Second, when evaluating ImplWitnessAccess, we were replacing .Self in
the LHS of rewrite constraints, but the `.Self` may itself have a type
that contains rewrite constraints. If one of those rewrite constraints
has nested ImplWitnessAccess instructions, we evaluate the new
ImplWitnessAccess, which again finds rewrite constraints to replace
`.Self` in, and we repeat forever. For this one we just stop replacing
.Self in the LHS of rewrite constraints. Since they are always against
.Self, we can always look in the access facet's type for a value.
While fixing ImplWitness access, also correct the lookup to search
through the types of nested ImplWitnessAccess instructions to find a
rewrite value, since it may find it at any level up to the eventual
`.Self`.
---------
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
We were treating ImplWitnessAccess as a concrete type, but that is
incorrect if its accessing a symbolic type value. This results in
concrete impl lookup queries failing to match a generic impl that is
built with a symbolic ImplWitnessAccess in its type structure, when the
query does not have the equivalent ImplWitnessAccess in its own type
structure.
We need to look in the top level facet being accessed through
ImplWitnessAccess for witnesses, such as in `T:! Z where .Z1 impls Y`
where `T` provides the witness for `T.Z1 as Y`. But we also need to look
in the facet type of the ImplWitnessAccess for witnesses, such as in
`T:! Z` for `interface Z { let Z1:! Y }`, where `T.Z1` provides the
witness for `T.Z1 as Y`.
To support that we give TypeIterator an iteration step for
ImplWitnessAccess before recursing into it, like we do for FacetValue.
While doing this, we make TypeIterator more recursive, by making less
special casing around the step from one inst into the next. Instead of
eagerly finding a SymbolicType, we consistently recurse back into the
big switch statement and have it decide the next iteration step. This
allows it to recurse into instructions like ImplWitnessAccess and
FacetValue in a consistent manner.
This enables searching facets like `T:! Z where .Z1 impls Y` for queries
like `T.Z1 as Y`, etc.
Any facet in the query self or the query target type may provide a
witness for the requirements of the impl lookup, so search through them
all.
We accept partially identified facet types in the query self, since
`Self` can be used inside a named constraint before it's fully
identified. But any use of `Self` being converted would put it in the
query self, not the query target, which would be some generic parameter
facet type that a type involving `Self` is being converted to.
TypeIterator is expanded to support this use case, by giving it the
ability to walk through FacetType's extend/impls constraints. We return
the facet values that we find in the iterator instead of a type id. And
we also include FacetValue instructions as an iterator step for clients
that want them, while also recursing through them.
A `where` expression nested inside a `T impls X` constraint makes
`.Self` ambiguous on the right-hand side of the `where` if `T` is
anything other than `.Self`. After the `where`, the value of a `.Self`
could be `T` or could be the value of `.Self` before the `impls`
constraint: the so-called top-level value of `.Self`.
Implicit use of `.Self` in designators is always allowed, and they are
bound (and replaced by a reference) to the inner-most possible value of
`.Self`. On the right-hand side of the nested `where` above, they have
the value `T as X`.
`.Self impls ...` is also always allowed, since it acts more as a
keyword here, and it always refers to the inner-most possible value of
`.Self`.
Any other explicit use of `.Self` is diagnosed when ambiguous, in any
kind of constraint. This is done in the handling of `WhereExpr` since it
has enough context to allow `.Self impls` (which is an explicit use)
while disallowing other explicit uses. And because it has non-canonical
instructions to work with, so it is able to diagnose errors with precise
locations.
Since `.Self` is no longer going to be marked with depth modifiers, the
eval of `WhereExpr` does not need an input facet value instruction
representing `.Self` to compare with, as they are now going to all be
equivalent. So revert it back to just looking for the `PeriodSelf` name
id, through a shared helper being introduced as `IsPeriodSelf`. And drop
the period self InstId from the `WhereExpr` instruction. This causes
most of the formatted SemIR changes.
Move helpers for working with and replacing `.Self` to their own file,
out of the `facet_type.h` header/cpp files. These are working with
`.Self` facet values more than facet types, though `.Self` is a name
that only exists inside the scope of a facet type.
This allows `T impls X` constraints to function, since they must contain
some reference to `.Self` in order to be valid. This should be
sufficient to support the interfaces we need for for loops over C++
range-for-compatible types.
We replace `.Self` in the following places:
- In a require decl, as we have a specific self facet to replace it with
from the declaration, either a user-specified facet or the symbolic
`Self`.
- When identifying a facet type, as we have a specific self that we are
identifying the facet type with. That self gets used for all `.Self`
references.
- Implicit `.Self` references on the RHS of an `impls` constraint when
building a facet type. The `.Self` references there no longer refer to
the top level self facet, so replace them with the facet that we now
know they refer to, which is found on the LHS of the `where` before the
`impls`.
- Rewrite constraints in impl lookup when validating them and comparing
them with constants from witnesses, which come from identifying a facet
type.
- Rewrite constraints in ImplWitnessAccess eval when comparing them with
constants from witnesses, which come from identifying a facet type.
Substitution is done through `SubstPeriodSelf`. It handles replacing
`.Self` and `.Self as type`, for a replacement facet that is either of
type FacetType or TypeType.
Eval currently diagnoses some ambiguous `.Self` references when doing
substitution of `.Self` but this is the incorrect place to do it, so
there are TODOs about moving this to name lookup. To support these
diagnostics there's some additional complexity in `SubstPeriodSelf` that
can go away once the TODOs are addressed, such as asking the caller if
they want to replace each `.Self`, in order for it to report a
diagnostic.
There are a number of follow-up work items here:
- Some TODO tests.
- Remove `SymbolicBindingType` since its intention was to support
`.Self` but we don't need it with this approach.
- Replace `.Self` in rewrite constraints of require decls.
- Replace `.Self` in rewrite constraints of impl as when constructing
the witness table.
- Reject explicit `.Self` in name lookup when it would be ambiguous.
- Officially disallow `.Self.A = B` in rewrite constraints in the design
docs, so that we don't have the case where `.A` is allowed but `.Self.A`
is not due to ambiguity.
The existing `GetCoreInterface` has linear-time complexity and adds more
than the search criteria to the `CoreInterfaceCache`. Adding a new field
to `Interface` changes this operation when building packages other than
`Core`, as this should only be set for the core library.
Add `InstIs`, `GetInstAs`, and `TryGetInstAs` which act on the
underlying constant instruction in a constant value, to save an explicit
call to `GetInstId`.
```carbon
context.insts().GetAs<InstT>(context.constant_values().GetInstId(const_id))
```
can now be written as simply
```carbon
context.constant_values().GetInstAs<InstT>(const_id)
```
For future work, we might provide `GetInst()` so that
`context.insts().Get(context.constant_values().GetInstId(const_id)` can
be shortened also.
Performing a lookup against `Self` inside the definition of the named
constraint leads to cycles, as described in the document [Self
contradictions in Named
Constraints](https://docs.google.com/document/d/17rn2XmME8o2MM4OJqatSVuMa1iYZ1PAgcNrf0PXR9Q4/edit?tab=t.0).
To prevent those cycles, this change introduces a large refactoring of
impl lookup.
The impl lookup done inside eval is reduced to only performing
monomorphization. That is it:
- Only looks for an provides final witnesses.
- Is not allowed to identify the facet type of the query self.
- Returns either a final witness or None (or an error)
The paths for finding non-final witnesses are now done outside of eval,
directly in the initial `LookupImplWitness()` function. If no final
witness it found through eval, the resulting non-final
`LookupImplWitness` instruction witness is returned. It does not produce
cycles to identify the facet type of query self outside of eval, since
that does not result in repeating the identification when resolving
specifics of the named constraint or require decl.
Move the ArrayStack for Context::require_impls_stack into a new class
which tracks a NamedConstraintId (or InterfaceId) for each frame of
RequireImplsIds, so that in type completion we always can find the
correct frame for a given named constraint which is still being defined,
in order to find the RequireImplsIds in the in-progress definition.
This commit creates an instance for any associated types in an interface
with a custom witness table. This unlocks interfaces designed for C++
interop that rely on arbitrary return types. For example,
`CppUnsafeDeref` becomes usable as of this commit.
This commit may have also implemented support for non-type associated
constants, but since we're lacking a practical test case, they're still
marked as TODO for the time being.
---------
Co-authored-by: Dana Jansens <danakj@orodu.net>
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
The self value can be a facet-value or a facet-value-as-type. The self
value used in `require` decls is the former. The the self value used for
identifying the facet type is the latter, we end up with two different
required interfaces in the identified facet type: one for each self
value.
Always canonicalize the self value to a facet value in identification.
Then dedupe the list of extend interfaces when constructing the
`IdentifiedFacetType` before counting them. And then impl lookup needs
to canonicalize its query self for comparing with the result from the
`IdentifiedFacetType`.
The type of the query self is looked into for a witness, but that type
may be unable to be identified. For example when the query is against
`Self` inside the declaration of a named constraint. Before this PR, we
would crash when identification failed. Now we produce a diagnostic.
This makes `RequireIdentifiedFacetType` take a `ContextScope` callback
(like it used to with an `AnnotationScope` callback) since all callers
now expect to handle diagnostics, and can provide useful context.
This is a followup to #6761.
Introduces `Context` and `SoftContext` messages, which can be introduced
through a `ContextBuilder`:
- The `Context` messages come before the diagnostic in the output.
- The first `Context` message steals the diagnostic level from the main
diagnostic, and turns the main diagnostic into a Note attached to the
context.
- A `SoftContext` message works similarly, but if it's preceeded by a
`Context` or `SoftContext` message, then it is dropped. This can be used
as a default/backup scope when nothing more interesting is provided up
the stack, such as in `TryEvalBlockForSpecific`.
The `ContextBuilder` is provided to a callback through
`Diagnostics::ContextScope`, an RAII type `AnnotationScope` but for
context messages.
This allows a high level operation to provide a context message like
"failed to identify facet type {0}" which will then be used as the error
if a diagnostic is produced during identification, with the latter
diagnostic attached as a note to explain why the contextual operation
failed.
In particular, this allows monomorphization errors (such as an array
bound being negative) to be attached to a higher lever operation instead
of being top-level diagnostics themselves, with the monomorphization
site being a note. This inverts the source code locations that appear in
the diagnostic, so that the top-level diagnostic points to the "user
code" which causes the monomorphization.
This is presented as an alternative strategy to #6753, which plumbed
diagnoser callbacks around to achieve the same goals.
We replace the diagnoser callbacks in type completion and operators with
ContextScope callbacks instead, which now provide better diagnostics for
monomorphization errors. Other callers to MakeSpecific do not yet have
ContextScopes introduced in order to turn monomorphization errors into
more interesting diagnostics.
This is related to #6727, but is generally a necessary fix even without
that issue. I'm not adding a specific test of #6727 because it should
also be covered by the tests in #6726.
Assisted-by: Google Antigravity with Gemini 3 Flash
Identifying a facet type takes both a self and facet type as a pair, and
then encode the self into the IdentifiedFacetType. This makes a
constraint that requires some _other_ type implements an interface
visible in the IdentifiedFacetType. And it will help to enable facet
types with `where T impls Z` for `T` that is not `.Self` in the future.
IdentifiedFacetTypes are now stored in a CanonicalValueStore instead of
a RelationalValueStore as they key is the combination of self and
(declared) facet type together now.
When the self-type is a facet value (has type FacetType) this is most
straightforward. But when it's a type we need to construct a FacetValue
to construct a specific for a require decl, to replace the generic
binding of the symbolic `Self`, which has type FacetType. To do so, we
make a FacetValue with an empty FacetType (equivalent to TypeType). This
prevents any looking for witnesses through the FacetType, which matches
what you can get from a type directly, requiring witnesses to come from
finding an `impl` decl.
Add additional InstNamer logic for such empty facet types so they print
as `<typename>.type.facet` if possible instead of as just `facet_value`.
Adds Inst::IsOneOf which takes a variadic generic parameter pack of
kinds to check against. Also add forwarding functions to TypeStore and
InstStore. Convert uses of the regex `Is<.*\|\|` to IsOneOf.
This is based on #6522
Pursuant to recent decisions on #6124, switch `Destroy` to use a
`CustomWitness` for its implementation. Right now this is manufacturing
no-op implementation functions on each lookup, which obviously isn't
ideal but is intended as a first pass. I'm mostly trying to find the
right balance between updating the approach to reflect new decisions,
while still breaking apart work in a way.
The `CoreInterface` logic is intended to build on `CoreIdentifier`
support. We have a number of additional interfaces that require
specialized logic, and that'll extend pretty far with C++ interop, so it
seemed easiest to have a generic function for it. That's what's
replacing the logic inside C++ interop that was doing string comparisons
(which could have already been moved to `CoreIdentifier`, I just missed
it in my first pass).
This adds `CustomWitness` support because the `Destroy` witnesses can be
imported cross-file. `CustomWitness` was previously only used for C++
types, which don't yet support import, which is why that wasn't
previously an issue. The addition of `query_specific_interface_id` is
similarly needed in order to get correct sorting of witness blocks when
imported.
This PR also removes builtin constraint logic (note this is in a
separate commit to help review; it's not a separate PR because it's
difficult to split apart without tests breaking). This had been made
generic with the expectation that destroy, copy, move, and conversions
would all need related support. Under the new decision, we are not going
to do blanket impls and will instead just manufacture a `CustomWitness`
for everything.
A lot of SemIR fingerprints change, but that's probably because the
addition of `Destroy` on core classes is yielding structural changes.
This delays the conversion of `query_self_const_id` until the actual
witness creation, mainly so that users of `BuildCustomWitness` don't
need to do extra work to ensure `GetFacetAsType` logic is
shared/applied. This is coming up for destroy logic.
We're going to want to track `Destroy` and some other interfaces in ways
similar to what the C++ logic wants. Rather than having both do their
own comparisons with similar values, this tries to centralize logic.
Note the prior
`context.identifiers().Get(interface.name_id.AsIdentifierId())` is also
obsolete due to #6486, this is just replacing it in a single swoop and
avoiding string comparisons as a consequence.
This reduces the function size from ~180 to 133. It removes early outs
once we begin the process of doing an impl lookup so that we cache the
result unconditionally at the end. It removes a second fallback call to
look for a C++ witness by tracking additional information about the
`Impl` that was found (if any) and just do the C++ lookup in one place
afterward.
If an impl lookup finds a final result, cache that and reuse it if we
perform the same lookup later.
In addition to reducing repeated work, this allows us to produce the
same result for repeated lookups that find a C++ operator. This isn't a
great solution to that problem, as it's not clear how to extend it to
behave correctly across import, but we don't have a solution for that
for C++ interop in general.
When performing impl lookup for `Core.Copy` for a C++ class type, look
for a copy constructor. If we find one, synthesize an impl witness that
calls the constructor.
This adds initial support for impl lookup to delegate to the C++ interop
logic for queries involving C++ types. For now, we don't implement the
rules from #6166 that compare a synthesized type structure for the C++
impl against the best Carbon type structure, but the framework for
building that support is established here.
Currently there is no caching of the lookup here, and we build unique
`ImplWitnessTable`s for each lookup, which leads to each impl lookup
producing a distinct facet value. This results in some errors in generic
contexts; this will be addressed in follow-up changes. This PR aims only
to support the non-generic case.
---------
Co-authored-by: Dana Jansens <danakj@orodu.net>
Co-authored-by: Carbon Infra Bot <carbon-external-infra@google.com>
When forming an IdentifiedFacetType, we collect interfaces named by
require decls in named constraints that the facet type refers to. These
interfaces come with a specific, but the require decl is inside an named
constraint which may be generic. So we need the specific being applied
to the containing named constraint to also be applied to the require
decl and its target interfaces.
This uncovered that the facet type in require decls was not being
imported correctly, as it was not being attached to the require decl's
generic. This is fixed by making import of RequireImplsDecl multiphase,
so that the decl instruction exists before we resolve the facet type
within it. And by pointing the generic importing machinery to the
RequireImplsDecl, and from there to the RequireImpls structure to get
the generic id.
Then `ImplStore::GetOrAddLookupBucket` can use an IdentifiedFacetType to
correctly get the interface being impl'd, both in the local and the
imported named constraint case. Which allows us to correctly diagnose
redeclarations in the impl file of an impl of an interface through a
named constraint. And to correctly _not_ diagnose them when the specific
in the generic named constraint differs from other decls.
Right now, the impl lookup can both fail to resolve the specific
definition because it's symbolic, and return a "final" constant because
it's a `final impl`. This is adding an instruction to help ensure the
specific is resolved.
The constant evaluation is fully recursive, but I'm not adding a TODO
since that's a known issue with impl lookup in general.
There are two uses I'm not converting here, that seem to want the
"shortest" behavior. For everything else, I'm going to `zip_equal` since
it's more restrictive.
I wish `zip` were named `zip_shortest`.
Proposal #5168 defines when a facet type must be identified or complete,
and what it means for an interface and a named constraint to be
identified or complete. This updates the toolchain to match the
requirements.
This implements identification of a facet type to require completed
named constraints and to include any interfaces from named constraints
into the resulting IdentifiedFacetType.
To complete a facet type, each interface in the IdentifiedFacetType, and
any interface named though a require declaration from them, must be
complete.
When the missing definition is diagnosed at the end of the file, the
witness is set to an error. Impl lookup was skipping impls entirely when
the witness was an error, which means a non-final LookupImplWitness
could be later evaluated against a specific and crash since the lookup
fails instead of returning the error.
The same crash could also occur when verifying poisoned queries hadn't
changed, but now it can find an ErrorInst witness instead, so it is
changed to handle that gracefully.
This requires declared FacetTypes to hold NamedConstraintIds (along with
a specific) that are named in an extend or impls requirement. We add
support to stringify and formatter to display the named constraints in
the facet type, and special case when a facet type contains a single
extend named constraint, like we did for a single extend interface.
This means that `RequireIndentifiedFacetType` can now fail, if the facet
type contains a forward-declared named constraint. Add the appropriate
diagnostics for each call to this function, and note the ones that
should change to `RequireCompleteFacetType` in the future with TODOs.
We also add tests for using facet types that can or can't be identified,
or completed, with named constraints in them.
A `final impl` can have a symbolic witness, but that witness is still
final. Using "final" here per discussion on
[#generics-and-templates](https://discord.com/channels/655572317891461132/941071822756143115/1428851511672312120).
I'm also changing the variant a little because `concrete_witness` was
only called when `has_concrete_value` was true, so it can be more
careful about its contract. Having a more explicit `None` also
simplifies `has_value`. I think it doesn't change the overall cost much
past that.
The `AppendLookupScopesForConstant` function had a special case for
`facet as type` which was overly broad (applying to all callers to the
function when only one caller needs it), and was confusingly overly
specific (applying to `facet as type` but not to `facet` constants).
We clarify all of this by moving it out to member access, and applying
it only to the case of looking into the type of `base_id`. In that case
we are doing member lookup into the facet itself, but since it's
symbolic we don't know the type to look into. And we don't defer the
lookup with a symbolic instruction, so we do the lookup into the facet's
type instead.
We add a helper function in member access, `ExtractFacetTypeForFacet` to
encapsulate this slightly-odd operation. It's odd because it ends up
getting *the type of the type* when the `base_id` has a facet as its
type.
The helper is now built on top of GetCanonicalFacetOrTypeValue() instead
of explicitly looking for FacetAccessType, which makes it work more
generally for any type instructions that represent a facet, including
SymbolicBindingType in the future.
While here document and improve clarity throughout the
`PerformActionHelper` for member access.
Previously it performed two kinds of operations, with a boolean
parameter to control whether it would unwrap FacetValue or not. This
made the function hard to explain as "canonicalization".
Now the contract of GetCanonicalFacetOrTypeValue is as follows:
1. For a facet value expression, it returns the canonical value of the
facet value.
2. For a `<facet value> as type` it returns the canonical value of the
`<facet value>`.
3. For other type expressions, it returns the canonical value of the
type.
1 and 2 together collapse together two representations of a facet value
(as a FacetType or as a TypeType) into a single canonical value, which
is important for constant comparison of facet values where the `as type`
is not meant to change the result. This is the case in impl lookups and
`.Self` comparisons.
The step of unwrapping `FacetValue` is only useful in the constant
evaluation of `LookupImplWitness` and is used to collapse *symbolic*
queries on `FacetValue(T)` and on `T` down to a single canonical value,
since they produce the same result later when `T` is replaced with a
facet value or type that can provide a concrete witness. This is now
extensively documented in the constant evaluation of
`LookupImplWitness`.
This change came out of a request/discussion in #6115 (see comment
https://github.com/carbon-language/carbon-lang/pull/6115#discussion_r2383696576).
When doing impl lookup with a constraint facet type including the
builtin `TypeCanAggregateDestroy`, we look at the type to see if it
satisfies it. However if the type is a facet value, we need to look at
the FacetType to see if the eventual concrete type is going to satisfy
it.
Note that we can do this check up front in the `LookupImplWitness()`
function without creating a symbolic instruction to be modified by
future specifics with a more precise type for the facet value, because
the result of `TypeCanAggregateDestroy` does not actually provide a
witness, so we don't need the final specific type.
This was noticed by removing the "shortcut" in convert for converting a
`FacetAccessType(<symbolic binding>)` to `typeof(<symbolic binding>)`.
By removing the shortcut, we go into impl lookup when checking `impl`
decls containing `TypeCanAggregateDestroy` via deduce.
This also does a little restructuring in the same direction, following
#6124.
Leads want `Destroy` to work similarly now for all types. As a
consequence, there doesn't seem to be as much benefit to splitting off
aggregate destruction. In this PR, the `type.destroy` function can now
be expected to destroy anything that's destructible; that means it'll be
usable for the `final fn` once that support is available.
Similarly, this gets rid of the impls other than the single blanket
impl, now using `type.can_destroy`. Since they all need to use the same
function, there's no benefit to splitting approaches. Also, now it can
just be a `final impl` since there should be no need for people to
create specializations -- if this blanket impl applies, it means the
`final fn` is the same.
This also slips in `partial` support since there's no reason to have it
diverge anymore. Also `abstract`, which I'm not sure is broadly testable
since most cases it'd come up, the `abstract` keyword is explicitly
detected/rejected.
Note though that this doesn't make any really big changes. It's just
realigning on the leads decision. I'm going this way to try to reduce
name-related churn for other changes.
Right now, the class destroy impl is incorrectly generated (first
discussed [in
Discord](https://discord.com/channels/655572317891461132/941071822756143115/1418614787449032826)).
If we want it to be correct, deferred definition logic would need to be
added, and the declaration would need to be moved inside the `class`
scope (along with whatever generic logic that needs).
This instead switches to a blanket impl, to avoid creating latent bugs
with generating the `impl` and function body in the wrong scope. This
approach uses the same blanket impl as aggregate destruction that was
added by #6098.
The intent here is to allow progress on other parts of `Destroy`. For
example, under this model the implementation of the function body could
be done as part of lowering the specific.
The main direction of this change is the edits to `destroy.carbon`
(matching in both prelude and min_prelude).
Previously there was a no-op blanket impl for `Destroy`, which hid all
missing implementations of `Destroy`. This does a few things:
- Sets up builtin aggregate destruction for struct and tuple types as
before, but also adds C++ class types and array types to the same
handling. (all as a TODO for actual implementation)
- Also maybe-unformed destruction, for now at least. (there's a chance I
may try a different approach on this, but the impl lookup wasn't working
as I'd hope in order to write it in code)
- Adds handlers for simple things that are easy to do in code: `type`,
`bool`, pointers. (because these are no-op destruction)
- Redirect `const T` destruction to `T` destruction.
This leaves as future issues:
- `partial T` destruction. (this can't be done similar to `const`
because it only works for non-`final` class types; I think `class`
definitions should just generate what's needed)
- Destruction of other prelude-provided types. (will probably come up as
we implement class destruction, that the adapted builtin type doesn't
implement `Destroy` -- but may end up special-casing that in a way that
moots it)
This moves the `&` operator from `facet_types.carbon` to
`convert.carbon` because more things need to handle type and now that
we're getting separate copy and destroy interfaces. It should be
low-cost (an interface and builtin) so hopefully this is the right
balance for complexity and re-use.
A few tests are also edited in order to focus them more on what they
intend to test, and avoid a `Destroy` dependency.
This is in support of a goal of changing the blanket `destroy` impl to
use (roughly):
```
private fn CanAggregateDestroy() -> type = "type.can_aggregate_destroy";
// Handles aggregate type destruction.
impl forall [AggregateDestroyT:! CanAggregateDestroy()] AggregateDestroyT as Destroy {
fn Op[addr self: Self*]() = "type.aggregate_destroy";
}
```
That isn't done here because there's still other issues that migrating
raises. What this *does* do is add the builtin functions, and in
particular, support to `FacetTypeInfo` to make `CanAggregateDestroy`
work.
The "special requirement" approach in `FacetTypeInfo` allows us to
support restricting a blanket impl under the current approach of impls.
Maybe we'll find a cleaner approach that can work in the future, but
this fits into the current model by propagating similar to other
requirements. I'm using an enum mask because we have a number of similar
things to add (e.g. copy, move) but I'm not sure we need a full vector.
A few alternatives considered were:
- Supporting syntax more like `where .Self impls
TypeCanAggregateDestroy(.Self, SupportedInterface,
UnsupportedInterface)`. I think it'd be a little cleaner, but requires
better compile-time evaluation in order to assess the type of the call.
Right now it's expected to be a `FacetType` too early to make this work,
and I was concerned about pouring too much more time down this route.
- Providing an actual interface, in particular doing name lookup back
into `Core.` for an interface. This would've added name lookup overhead,
and the question of whether an `impl` exists.
- Generating an interface. This avoids the name lookup, but would still
raise the question of whether an `impl` should also be generated. Work
I've previously done generating interfaces for class destruction also
feels complex to both write and understand (an unfortunate issue).
- Still modeling as an `ImplsConstraint`, for example by defining a
special `InterfaceId::CanAggregateDestroy = -2` similar to what we do on
other ids. I was hesitant because of how this expands the number of
modes of `InterfaceId`, and things for consuming code to watch out for,
for what feels like a relatively niche set of use-cases that are only
interface-like.
---------
Co-authored-by: Dana Jansens <danakj@orodu.net>
This avoids impl lookups involving, say, `Core.Int` pulling in all ~65
impls in "prelude/types/int", which resulted in a lot of unnecessary
importing work, followed by a lot of unnecessary inst namer and inst
formatter work.
Before:
```
Ran 1335 tests in 6186 ms wall time, 146818 ms across threads
Slowest tests:
- toolchain/check/testdata/interop/cpp/function/arithmetic_types_bridged.carbon: 5611 ms, 5532 ms in Run
- toolchain/check/testdata/interop/cpp/function/operators.carbon: 2034 ms, 1981 ms in Run
- toolchain/check/testdata/primitives/import_symbolic.carbon: 1796 ms, 1786 ms in Run
- toolchain/lower/testdata/operators/arithmetic.carbon: 1729 ms, 1728 ms in Run
- toolchain/lower/testdata/function/generic/call_recursive_sccs_deep.carbon: 1700 ms, 1697 ms in Run
[==========] 1335 tests from 1 test suite ran. (682 ms total)
```
After:
```
Ran 1335 tests in 2419 ms wall time, 109587 ms across threads
Slowest tests:
- toolchain/check/testdata/interop/cpp/function/arithmetic_types_bridged.carbon: 1748 ms, 1665 ms in Run
- toolchain/check/testdata/interop/cpp/function/operators.carbon: 1106 ms, 1057 ms in Run
- toolchain/lower/testdata/function/generic/call_recursive_diamond.carbon: 1044 ms, 1041 ms in Run
- toolchain/lower/testdata/function/generic/call_recursive_sccs_deep.carbon: 1015 ms, 1012 ms in Run
- toolchain/lower/testdata/operators/arithmetic.carbon: 998 ms, 997 ms in Run
[==========] 1335 tests from 1 test suite ran. (652 ms total)
```
That's still slower than it should be, but a large improvement
nonetheless.
Fixes#6029
In order to verify rewrite constraints at the end of
`LookupImplWitness()` we need to replace references to associated
constants in the query facet type with values that come from the query's
self. To do this, we find any `ImplWitnessAccess` that is a reference to
`.Self` and replace its witness with the witness found through the impl
lookup process, if the interfaces match. This allows the
`ImplWitnessAccess` to resolve to a concrete value if that witness was
concrete. Then we just need to compare that for each rewrite constraint
the lhs and rhs are the same constant value. If they differ, the self
provided a different value for one side (either through its own facet
value constraints or through an associated impl), or the self did not
provide a value at all.
For now, only .Self references in the top-level facet type are
rewritten. Nested facet types are not, even if they contain a .Self
reference up to the top level facet value. This will be addressed by
adding numbering to the EntityName of of .Self in a BindSymbolicName.
See the third model in
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Yt-i5AmF76LSvD4TrWRIAE_92kii6j5yFiW-S7ahzlg/edit?tab=t.0
for the plan. For now, there is a TODO addressing this.
Per discussion at
https://github.com/carbon-language/carbon-lang/pull/5875#issuecomment-3137288037,
a different approach to the same solution.
A key difference is that whereas #5875 would build a `TypeStructure`
containing `ConcreteType{error}`, this instead just returns nothing.
This means impls with errors can't be compared in the same way, though
I'm not sure how much impact that'll really have (I've added a test here
to show a case where it seemed interesting to see what effect it'd have,
and it seems to have none).
---------
Co-authored-by: Dana Jansens <danakj@orodu.net>
Undo changes that were meant to prevent use of a reference into
`ValueStore` after being invalidated. After #5576, the `ValueStore`
makes such references stable, so there's no need to worry about
invalidation.
This changes `ToImplicit` to `AsDesugared`, and adds a
`GetLocIdForDesugaring` to `InstStore`.
In particular, I'm motivated by the latter, to make it clearer what the
intended call convention is.
Outside of `match_first` this adds diagnostics for invalid non-final and
final `impl` declarations in line with those being proposed in
https://github.com/carbon-language/carbon-lang/pull/5337.
- Two non-final `impl`s with the exact same type structure is invalid.
- A `final impl` that matches the self/constraint of another `impl` as a
query would always be preferred, making the second one invalid.
- Two `final impl`s that overlap (have compatible type structures) in
different files is invalid.
- Two `final impl`s that overlap (have compatible type structures) in
the same file is invalid outside of `match_first`.
- A `final impl` in a different file from its root self type and
interface is invalid.
We add tests for all these scenarios as well as correct scenarios.
The "compatible" test for two type structures was being done
symmetrically, which is incorrect. We want it to test that a query type
structure is the same _or more specific_ in a compatible way with an
impl's type structure. This is corrected in the implementation, and the
diagnostics now have to test both directions to get the desired output,
as expected.
---------
Co-authored-by: josh11b <15258583+josh11b@users.noreply.github.com>
Such impls will never be used, so they should not exist. And test that a
final impl partially overlapping a non-final impl is accepted.
There is a question about a final impl partially overlapping a final
impl that is part of
https://github.com/carbon-language/carbon-lang/pull/5337
Dana Jansens
Christopher Di Bella
Jon Ross-Perkins
Geoff Romer
