The key changes are:
- Function output parameters are now prefixed with `out`, and more
consistently formatted as named parameters.
- Function and inst output arguments are now written as part of the inst
form, rather than as one of the inst arguments.
As a drive-by fix, this also changes `Temporary::storage_id` from
`DestInstId` to `InstId`, because it doesn't represent an output
parameter of the `Temporary` inst itself.
See the review of
[#6532](https://github.com/carbon-language/carbon-lang/pull/6532) and
[this Discord
discussion](https://discord.com/channels/655572317891461132/999638000126394370/1458268977020141589)
for additional background.
Also clarify and enforce that `ConversionTarget::init_id` is used only
as storage for in-place initialization, and correspondingly rename it to
`storage_id`.
Not all functions have a return slot, and once we have composite forms,
functions will be able to have any number of return slots. Obtaining a
unique return slot for a function only makes sense in `returned var`
handling.
The main changes here are:
- Introducing `InitForm` and `RefForm` to represent initializing and
reference forms (the two return forms currently supported by the
parser).
- Introducing the `FormType` singleton inst to represent their type
(i.e. `Core.Form`).
- Emitting an inst representing a function's declared return form as
part of handling the function signature.
The return form inst is currently ignored. Subsequent PRs will expose it
in `SemIR::Function` and use it to determine the form of call
expressions.
Pursuant to recent decisions on #6124, switch `Destroy` to use a
`CustomWitness` for its implementation. Right now this is manufacturing
no-op implementation functions on each lookup, which obviously isn't
ideal but is intended as a first pass. I'm mostly trying to find the
right balance between updating the approach to reflect new decisions,
while still breaking apart work in a way.
The `CoreInterface` logic is intended to build on `CoreIdentifier`
support. We have a number of additional interfaces that require
specialized logic, and that'll extend pretty far with C++ interop, so it
seemed easiest to have a generic function for it. That's what's
replacing the logic inside C++ interop that was doing string comparisons
(which could have already been moved to `CoreIdentifier`, I just missed
it in my first pass).
This adds `CustomWitness` support because the `Destroy` witnesses can be
imported cross-file. `CustomWitness` was previously only used for C++
types, which don't yet support import, which is why that wasn't
previously an issue. The addition of `query_specific_interface_id` is
similarly needed in order to get correct sorting of witness blocks when
imported.
This PR also removes builtin constraint logic (note this is in a
separate commit to help review; it's not a separate PR because it's
difficult to split apart without tests breaking). This had been made
generic with the expectation that destroy, copy, move, and conversions
would all need related support. Under the new decision, we are not going
to do blanket impls and will instead just manufacture a `CustomWitness`
for everything.
A lot of SemIR fingerprints change, but that's probably because the
addition of `Destroy` on core classes is yielding structural changes.
The impl's body block has to end before we make its ImplDecl
instruction, and the witness instructions come later, so they don't end
up in the body block. Currently they just end up in the enclosing (file,
typically, or class) scope block.
Add a new InstBlockId to Impl for holding witness instructions, and
explicitly insert them into that block. Then include those instructions
into the scope of the Impl for naming, and format them into the Impl
right after the body block.
This is based on #6484
Instead of naming the root namespace `package` (because it's accessed by
the `package` keyword), change it to use the current package name. Note,
buried in the checksum changes,
`toolchain/check/testdata/package_expr/fail_not_found.carbon`:
```
- // CHECK:STDERR: fail_not_found.carbon:[[@LINE+4]]:16: error: member name `x` not found in `package` [MemberNameNotFoundInInstScope]
+ // CHECK:STDERR: fail_not_found.carbon:[[@LINE+4]]:16: error: member name `x` not found in `Main` [MemberNameNotFoundInInstScope]
```
for:
```
// CHECK:STDERR: var y: i32 = package.x;
// CHECK:STDERR: ^~~~~~~~~
```
I'll leave it to you if you prefer this; the alternative I see is to
just rename `IsCorePackage` to `IsImportedCorePackage`, and/or change it
to a helper that takes a `Context` and does the right thing with
`parse_tree` (which, I need for `Destroy`-related reasons and was my
default approach).
Explicitly run `RequireCompleteType` for an impl's facet type constraint
in two places:
- For a new `Impl` declaration that is `extend`
- At the start of the `Impl` definition
Stop trying to RequireCompleteType in the definition when constructing
the witness. If we have a rewrite of a name in `.Self`, then we can
construct a full witness, otherwise we defer to the definition.
Now GetOrAddImpl does not need to track `is_definition` anymore, so we
remove a lot of plumbing.
We inline the `AllocateFacetTypeImplWitness` since it has a single
caller and it is just 2 lines, to help improve understanding of the
steps and comments in setting up the impl definition.
Note that this puts the `RequreCompleteType` instruction into the
definition's generic eval block always, avoiding the issue of ensuring
that each generic redecl has the exact same instructions, and forcing
coordination to have `RequireCompleteType` inserted into every
declaration's eval block or none. The result also more closely matches
the design, with the complete type not being required until inside the
definition.
This is part of #6420 which is being split up into a chain of smaller
PRs. It is based on #6469.
I need this in a forthcoming PR, to reliably get the `Function` that was
originally used to build a `Call` inst, but even as a stand-alone
change, it seems to nicely improve the textual SemIR.
This separates the return type from the return pattern, and replaces the
return pattern with a block of return patterns. This is a step toward
support for `ref` returns (where there's no corresponding return
pattern) and compund-form returns (where there may be multiple return
patterns).
I think these are obsolete, at least as far as I can tell. The former
appears tested (adding to be sure), the latter looks like it may no
longer occur.
Just as names from an `extend` scope get included in the containing
scope, so do errors. Apply this logic to `extend require impls`,
propagating any errors up.
This is based on #6465.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
This is a prerequisite for support for interop with C++ template names.
No behavior change here, except that it sadly changes the fingerprinting
for a lot of tests.
The FacetTypeId should never be used directly, since the RequireImpls is
a generic and the facet type may be parameterized by generic bindings.
So instead, it should be accessed through GetConstantValueInSpecific,
which works with the facet type InstId that is also already present on
RequireImpls. This change to use GetConstantValueInSpecific was done in
#6435, so the FacetTypeId is now unused except in formatting. So we can
remove it.
This depends on #6435.
Right now, the impl lookup can both fail to resolve the specific
definition because it's symbolic, and return a "final" constant because
it's a `final impl`. This is adding an instruction to help ensure the
specific is resolved.
The constant evaluation is fully recursive, but I'm not adding a TODO
since that's a known issue with impl lookup in general.
Identifying a facet type is an operation on a pair of (self type, facet
type). It substitutes that self in as the `Self` of any require
declarations in order to form the set of (self type, SpecificInterface)
pairs that constitute the requirements of the IdentifiedFacetType.
Currently we don't pass around any self type, and assume all require
declarations are written against `Self` but this will change in the
future.
By contrast, type completion is done in the abstract and does not form
specifics for the require declarations. The purpose of type completion
is to enumerate the scopes where name lookup can occur and ensure they
are completed.
With this change, type completion is:
- No longer built on top of identification for facet types.
- Recursively ensures all `extend` scopes are complete since name lookup
can find symbols in them.
We add some test cases that demonstrate consistency between a resolving
the specific of a generic class, and a generic interface/constraint,
both used in a type position. In all cases, an invalid specific is not
materialized for the type completion when the specific's arguments are
used in a non-extend context. But they specific is materialized and
checked for type completion when in an extend context (extend impl or
extend require).
Type completion itself does not need to recurse into named constraints
or interfaces as the `extend require` declarations require the type to
be complete immediately, just as for `extend impl` in a class.
We had a test (`fail_incomplete_where.carbon`) with `impl as J where
.Self impls K` and `J` is incomplete, which used to be diagnosed but no
longer is, because we don't require non-extend interfaces to be complete
in type completion, nor in identification. The test was trying to test
the presence of rewrite constraints though, which it didn't even use. So
we remove the diagnostic that we can't hit anymore and replaced it with
a TODO, and add a test that should reach that TODO once qualified
rewrite constraints work.
This continues work to eliminate pending generics/specifics and get them
to be interleaved with instruction imports. I'm trying to use
`FinishGenericOrDone` here as a way to help ensure that code correctly
handles generics, where the simple alternative would be for each
`TryResolveTypedInst` call `SetGenericData` directly (but which might
make it easier to call the wrong `ResolveResult` function, and we do
need the `GenericId`s to be passed).
Every test that used `addr` before #6283 should be using `ref` after
this PR. In most cases that was done in #6283, but this PR transitions a
few that I missed in that first pass. In addition, #6283 cloned the old
`addr` tests from `foo.carbon` to `foo_addr.carbon` in order to maintain
test coverage during the transition; this PR removes those cloned tests.
When importing an Interface or NamedConstraint, walk the block of
`RequireImplsId`s, and for each one:
- Import the RequireImplsDecl from it, which also imports the
`RequireImpls` structure and its id.
- Collect those decls and build a block of `RequireImplsId`s for the
local SemIR to reference from the Interface or NamedConstraint.
The import of RequireImplsDecl is done in a single phase instead of
three, unlike other decls. This is possible since require declarations
have no name, so they can't be referenced by instructions inside them,
thus there's no cycles to concern ourselves with.
Give TupleLiteral and StructLiteral a constant value, if their contents
have constant values. Their constant values are TupleValue and
StructValue respectively. This supports their ability to convert to a
constant type (or facet type).
This way when deduce finds a TupleLiteral as the argument to a
_symbolic_ facet type, it can also find a constant value to use for that
argument. This allows deduction to move onto step two, where it can
substitute into the symbolic parameter from previous deduced arguments,
and then perform the conversion from the TupleValue to the desired facet
type.
Allow `PerformBuiltinConversion()` to convert from a canonical
TupleValue or StructValue to `type` instead of only from literals. Then,
also support conversion from a symbolic binding of type TupleType or
StructType to `type`.
They are not used for impl lookup or verifying anything yet, but now
they appear in the textual semir.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
The `RequireDecl` instruction points, via a `RequireImplsId` to a
`RequireImpls` structure in a `ValueStore`. That structure holds the
self-type and facet type, as well as the generic id and parent scope.
`RequireImpls` is always a generic since it only appears in an
`interface` or `constraint`, which both have a generic parameter `Self`
applied to all their members.
The `RequireDecl` instruction evaluates to itself, but drops the
decl_block_id since the instructions within the `require` declaration
are not required in the canonical value which is only used for import.
And import will want to import the `RequireImpls` structure along with
the `Interface` or `NamedConstraint` structure it is in, rather than
recreate it from the decl's instructions. This also avoids repeating all
the instructions within the `require` decl in the textual semir's
constants block.
Adding the `RequireImpls` to the `Interface` or `NamedConstraint`
structure is not yet done, so they are not available for impl lookup or
import yet.
Do this even if the operand is a `ConstType` instruction. This better
preserves the source form of the type, and avoids a special case.
Repeated `const`s are already flattened in constant evaluation, and this
special case also didn't prevent forming a `ConstType` whose operand is
`const` in general, only cases where the operand happens to literally be
a `ConstType` instruction.
This reverts commit eed21f6439.
Format the entity name into the instruction name for a FacetAccessType
of a SymbolicBinding. This means (T as type) gets formatted as
`T.as_type` instead of just as `as_type` for the non-canonical
FacetAccessType instruction. The same is already true for the canonical
SymbolicBindingType.
This requires declared FacetTypes to hold NamedConstraintIds (along with
a specific) that are named in an extend or impls requirement. We add
support to stringify and formatter to display the named constraints in
the facet type, and special case when a facet type contains a single
extend named constraint, like we did for a single extend interface.
This means that `RequireIndentifiedFacetType` can now fail, if the facet
type contains a forward-declared named constraint. Add the appropriate
diagnostics for each call to this function, and note the ones that
should change to `RequireCompleteFacetType` in the future with TODOs.
We also add tests for using facet types that can or can't be identified,
or completed, with named constraints in them.
They don't get stored anywhere yet, but this type checks the
declarations and diagnoses errors in their form, such as not placing a
facet type after `impls` or a type before it.
#6289 absentmindedly added fields in more places, and this is undoing
that plus further fixes.
This does some cleanup of types with relation to singletons. For
`TypeType` and `ErrorInst`, they're always complete due to a
`SetComplete` call in `file.cpp`. For `CppVoidType`, it's intended to be
incomplete by construction, and so a `TypeId` should be okay. The intent
though on not generally providing these had been that `GetSingletonType`
needs to be called to get a type to be marked as complete.
In the case of `AutoType`, removing `TypeId`does change a small printing
detail. I think that's old legacy that's just been carried forward.
Otherwise, for both `InstType` and `AutoType`, I've added
`GetSingletonType` calls where they were used in order to ensure
completeness is applied correctly. These calls cause small SemIR
permutations.
This causes `AutoType` to be seen by lowering, so I'm adding a
placeholder for it. Also merging two functions that look like they're
identical in intent -- not sure why they're separate.
---------
Co-authored-by: Dana Jansens <danakj@orodu.net>
We give `Self` in an interface/constraint a location so it's not elided
when trying to dump the interface/constraint. We use the location of the
start of the definition, which is the scope for which the `Self` is
constructed and is available in.
The error message was saying "generic interface" but should say "generic
constraint"
There is one test that demonstrates the error message for interfaces,
but it's in tests for overloads, so add a more clearly dedicated test
for interface too.
`ImplWitnessTablePlaceholder` is the only non-type singleton instruction
(`ErrorInst` is a type; while `ImplWitnessTablePlaceholder` exposes
`TypeInstId`, it's only used as an `InstId`).
In order to allow simpler handling of singleton instructions, replace
`ImplWitnessTablePlaceholder::TypeInstId` uses with
`InstId::ImplWitnessTablePlaceholder`. Since the placeholder instruction
was never evaluated, this has no significant effect on behavior.
---------
Co-authored-by: Dana Jansens <danakj@orodu.net>
This defines `Cpp.void` as a custom type.
`Cpp.void*` is mapped to C++ `void*`.
Not supported yet: Conversions from and to other pointer types.
C++ Interop Demo:
```carbon
// main.carbon
library "Main";
import Core library "io";
import Cpp inline '''
#include <cstdio>
auto GetPointer() -> void* _Nonnull {
static int x = 8;
return &x;
}
auto GetValue(void* _Nonnull ptr) -> int {
return *static_cast<int*>(ptr);
}
''';
fn Run() -> i32 {
let ptr: Cpp.void* = Cpp.GetPointer();
Core.Print(Cpp.GetValue(ptr));
return 0;
}
```
```shell
$ bazel-bin/toolchain/carbon compile main.carbon
$ bazel-bin/toolchain/carbon link main.o --output=demo
$ ./demo
8
```
Part of #6280.
This is to avoid edge cases where there are multiple `ConstType`
instructions, which code may not handle appropriately. I was thinking
about this for #6279
This resolves a TODO in `expr_info.cpp` by using the inst kind rather
than the bound value to track the binding's category.
Since we're churning all the `bind_name` insts in testdata anyway, I'm
also taking this opportunity to align the inst naming with the design's
terminology, by calling these insts "bindings" (this aspect of the PR is
dependent on #6231 resolving an ambiguity in that terminology). For
consistency we'll need to rename several other insts as well (see the
TODO on `RefBinding`); I'm deferring that to a separate PR to minimize
the review load, but I think those name changes are in-scope for this
review.
When deducing arguments for generic parameters of an `impl`, the
deduction calls `Convert` on the input arguments. Often, the input
argument is a facet, and needs to be converted to a type via
FacetAccessType in order to produce a different facet. These
instructions end up being added to the semir, but only their constant
values are needed for the resulting specific returned from Deduce.
In the best case, these extra instructions are just noise in the semir,
or they just cause instruction names to get differentiated with larger
suffixes.
In the worst case, these extra instructions contain references to
instructions from a generic context, and leak them out of that generic
context and into another. In particular, when importing a
LookupImplWitness instruction, the re-evaluation of it can do deduce
(when the lookup is against a generic `impl`). The instructions created
in Deduce are not part of the import, and end up referring to imported
instructions from the local context, which leads to confusion in the
toolchain, and can crash.
The `import_self_specific.carbon` test demonstrates this. It causes the
`I.F` function to be imported from the `I` interface when building the
witness table for the `impl`. Doing so imports the specific of `C` which
includes a LookupImplWitness for `Self.Accoc` in `I`. The `Self` is a
BindSymbolicName with generic binding index 0, in `I`. When Convert
creates instructions in the generic `impl forall D`, however, they end
up referencing and including this BindSymbolicName into its eval block.
But the generic binding 0 in the `impl` is a very different thing (a
value of type `E`). This confusion leads to crashes.
This change makes dumping and debugging work again with InstIds that are
now tagged with the CheckIRId. The textual representation of an InstId
is changed from `irN.instM` back to `instM` but the `M` is now a hex
value with the tag as part of it, which is the same number that is
physically in the `InstId::index` field. This prevents any cases where
we would potentially print incorrect values for large InstIds.
We teach the `dump` command in lldb to parse hex values for InstId so
that we can paste these numbers back into the debugger.
The SymbolicBindingType refers to the type value that will be
substituted in for the BindSymbolicName, but holds onto the EntityNameId
from the BindSymbolicName instead of (or in addition to, for now) the
instruction.
The EntityNameId will be used to look in the ScopeStack to find the
witnesses either from the BindSymbolicName instruction, or other
instructions that specify `impls` constraints against the EntityName.
This will allow us to have the `T` in `I(T)` resolve to a `.Self`
reference in the type so that we get type equality with the binding's
type: `T:! I(.Self)`.
When deducing an argument against a type that is `<facet value> as type`
we don't care about the `as type` part of that expression. We want to
find an argument that can convert to the `FacetType` of the facet value
for the generic binding that is the `<facet value>`.
This was done after-the-fact in the Deduce switch, but we move this
canonicalization step to be more explicit and done up front at the start
of the Deduce loop. This:
- Avoids a trip through the Deduce loop for a `FacetAccessType`
parameter, just to deduce through it in the switch, which avoids convert
and creation of extraneous constant values.
- Uses the `GetCanonicalFacetOrTypeValue()` function so that when we add
`SymbolicBindingType` handling to that function it will apply to Deduce
as well correctly, instead of needing to handle both in the switch.
This also does a little restructuring in the same direction, following
#6124.
Leads want `Destroy` to work similarly now for all types. As a
consequence, there doesn't seem to be as much benefit to splitting off
aggregate destruction. In this PR, the `type.destroy` function can now
be expected to destroy anything that's destructible; that means it'll be
usable for the `final fn` once that support is available.
Similarly, this gets rid of the impls other than the single blanket
impl, now using `type.can_destroy`. Since they all need to use the same
function, there's no benefit to splitting approaches. Also, now it can
just be a `final impl` since there should be no need for people to
create specializations -- if this blanket impl applies, it means the
`final fn` is the same.
This also slips in `partial` support since there's no reason to have it
diverge anymore. Also `abstract`, which I'm not sure is broadly testable
since most cases it'd come up, the `abstract` keyword is explicitly
detected/rejected.
Note though that this doesn't make any really big changes. It's just
realigning on the leads decision. I'm going this way to try to reduce
name-related churn for other changes.
Locations are similarly fragile, because adding a comment changes them.
This has made me pause when making prelude changes in #6144, so dropping
them for those cases.
Instruction ids aren't actually that interesting outside debugging, and
can be churny when doing other structural changes. I've seen this in
particular when doing singleton changes, which bump every instruction
id.
Note there are still other ways fragility from locations can crop up.
This shouldn't be considered a complete fix, but hopefully a small
improvement.
Given `fn f(T:! I, x: T)`, we have a facet type `I`, a facet value `T`
and a value `x` of type `FacetAccessType(T)`.
Previously we explicitly handled the case of member access on `x.F`
where the type is a `FacetAccessType` by looking through it at the facet
value, and then at its facet type. This is already something that impl
lookup does for us, so we can remove this special case.
We also previously had a complex branch handling the case `T.F` on a
facet value, because `PerformImplLookup()` in member access is expecting
a `TypeId`, not a facet value. However, the first thing that branch does
is convert the facet value to a type expression, forming a
`FacetAccessType`.
Unfortuntely, when combined, if we had `x.F` we would convert it from a
value of type `FacetAccessType` to a facet value, and then convert that
to a type as a `FacetAccessType` again. We see this extra
`FacetAccessType` disappear from the SemIR after this change.
In this change, we remove both the inlined replacement of
`PerformImplLookup()` and the explicit handling of `FacetAccessType`. We
drive all member access lookups on the `base_id`'s type through a single
`PerformImplLookup()` call. If the `base_id` is a facet value, to get
the TypeId to look into, we convert the facet value to a
`FacetAccessType`, reducing the complex special cases down to a single
line.
This makes convert more consistent, it always makes a FacetAccessType
for a facet value, rather than only doing so after lookup returns. The
intention for this is that FacetAccessType will evaluate to
SymbolicBindingType in the future, so this will expose that constant
value to impl lookup instead of the original facet value, which will
avoid impl lookup having to deal with `.Self` or `BindSymbolicName`
specifically.
Right now, the class destroy impl is incorrectly generated (first
discussed [in
Discord](https://discord.com/channels/655572317891461132/941071822756143115/1418614787449032826)).
If we want it to be correct, deferred definition logic would need to be
added, and the declaration would need to be moved inside the `class`
scope (along with whatever generic logic that needs).
This instead switches to a blanket impl, to avoid creating latent bugs
with generating the `impl` and function body in the wrong scope. This
approach uses the same blanket impl as aggregate destruction that was
added by #6098.
The intent here is to allow progress on other parts of `Destroy`. For
example, under this model the implementation of the function body could
be done as part of lowering the specific.
Dana Jansens
Geoff Romer
Jon Ross-Perkins
Richard Smith
Boaz Brickner