This implements a few closely related features:
- Starts merging namespaces discovered inside imports.
- Stores results of cross-package name lookup as an entry inside the
scope.
- Note this is particularly visible with `i32`.
- Moves more of the imported instructions to the import scope.
Note this is primarily for executing the namespace TODO in check.cpp,
which is removed here.
`testdata/namespace/merging_with_indirections.carbon` tests key
behavior.
---------
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
Instead of reusing instructions from the generic entity in the eval
block, rebuild constants in the same way we rebuild types. The previous
attempt to not rebuild these constants assumed that every constant used
in a generic would be built in that generic, and not referenced directly
or referenced from some enclosing scope, which isn't true in practice
and is a fragile assumption in any case.
We could add back some reuse of instructions from the generic -- if we
happen to see the right instruction to build a constant, we could
opportunistically reuse it -- but given the complexity added by doing
so, I'm not pursuing that here.
Now that the eval block for a generic consists of instructions uniquely
owned by that generic, rather than often being shared with another
entity, include the generic in the formatted SemIR output. I'm using the
same scope name for the generic object itself as for the parameterized
class / function / interface, because there are very frequently
references between them and this keeps the IR simpler and more readable,
and avoids needing to invent a second name for the scope.
Note this isn't implementing checking through imports. The parse node
there is harder to access through the context, so would require
examining the entity in order to get the import declaration, to get at
the ImportIR. We also don't have a parse tree attached in that case, and
would need to add one to SemIR::File. But I believe we do want to add
that, so it's explicitly a TODO.
Note GetTokenText re-lexes literal values, so there's a bit of potential
overhead there. Not sure if we want a more efficient manner for
comparing in cases like this.
Also adds import_ir_scope to namespace formatting. I'd done this as an
aid for #4153, and am splitting it out.
---------
Co-authored-by: Geoff Romer <gromer@google.com>
Changes crash messages to start printing verbose forms of instructions,
rather than just the ID. Fixes some indentation issues with stacks. Also
switches unexpected inst formatting, because now there are lots, and
it'd be helpful to know where they are.
This uses a pimpl pattern for Formatter due to the number of member
functions on Formatter. Maybe we should refactor that, but this didn't
feel like a good place to do so.
Note, I have two concerns about this change... to note them here, to
make sure others are considering them when evaluating the
implementation:
1. Some instructions are very verbose to print, as evidenced by the
fn_decl printing (which includes function params) or scope printing
(which includes scope members).
- I'm not sure whether there's a way to simply reduce this, as it seems
essential to the requested printing of instructions.
- Long-term, we may at least want to limit the number of lines printed
here. However, I've already spent a fair amount of time here and I think
it's in a good state to evaluate.
2. Increased complexity in the crash handler may result in crash
messages failing to generate.
- For example, a crash in Formatter (and its deps, such as InstNamer or
location handling) prevents a stack from being printed. I'm pretty sure
I've written crashes in Formatter before.
Here's an example crash snippet (generated by adding a crash inside
`return` handling) before:
```
2. NodeStack:
0. FunctionDefinitionStart -> function2
1. ReturnStatementStart -> no value
2. IntLiteral -> inst+26
inst_block_stack_:
0. block<invalid> {inst+0, inst+1, inst+2, inst+23}
1. block9 {inst+26}
param_and_arg_refs_stack:
args_type_info_stack_:
```
And after:
```
2. Check::Context
NodeStack:
0. FunctionDefinitionStart: function2
1. ReturnStatementStart: no value
2. IntLiteral:
unexpected.inst+26.loc12_10: i32 = int_literal 0 [template = constants.%.2]
inst_block_stack_:
0. block<invalid> {
package: <namespace> = namespace [template] {
.Core = unexpected.inst+2
.F = unexpected.inst+23.loc11_22
}
unexpected.inst+1 = import Core
unexpected.inst+2: <namespace> = namespace unexpected.inst+1, [template] {}
unexpected.inst+23.loc11_22: %F.type = fn_decl @F [template = constants.%F] {
unexpected.inst+9.loc11_9: init type = call constants.%Bool() [template = bool]
unexpected.inst+10.loc11_9: type = value_of_initializer unexpected.inst+9.loc11_9 [template = bool]
unexpected.inst+11.loc11_9: type = converted unexpected.inst+9.loc11_9, unexpected.inst+10.loc11_9 [template = bool]
unexpected.inst+12.loc11_6: bool = param b
@F.%b: bool = bind_name b, unexpected.inst+12.loc11_6
unexpected.inst+19.loc11_18: init type = call constants.%Int32() [template = i32]
unexpected.inst+20.loc11_18: type = value_of_initializer unexpected.inst+19.loc11_18 [template = i32]
unexpected.inst+21.loc11_18: type = converted unexpected.inst+19.loc11_18, unexpected.inst+20.loc11_18 [template = i32]
@F.%return: ref i32 = var <return slot>
}
}
1. block9 {
unexpected.inst+26.loc12_10: i32 = int_literal 0 [template = constants.%.2]
}
param_and_arg_refs_stack:
args_type_info_stack_:
```
When forming a specific (previously called a generic instance), evaluate
the eval block of the generic to determine the values of any constants
used in that specific. The majority of the work here is updating
eval.cpp so that it can use the results of prior evaluations in the same
block when computing later values.
Include the computed results in the formatted SemIR output.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
For each generic, build a list of instructions describing the
computations we need to do when resolving an instance of the generic:
this is a list of the instance-specific constants and types that the
generic uses. Another way of viewing this list is as a block of Carbon
SemIR code that is evaluated in order to form an instance of the generic
-- this is referenced in the code as the "eval block" for the generic.
For each instruction in the generic whose type or value is a symbolic
constant, replace that type or constant value with a symbolic reference
that says "to find the actual type or value, look at index N in the list
of values for the generic instance".
For an instruction with a symbolic constant value, we can just add that
instruction to our list. For an instruction with a symbolic constant
type, however, we may not have a corresponding instruction computing the
type within the generic and may need to build a new instruction, but
will reuse one where possible. In the case where we build a new
instruction, we use the existing substitution code to build the type
within the eval block.
For now, this transformation is only done in the declaration region of
the generic, not in the definition region. Also, we map back from the
symbolic references to the underlying constant value in a few places
where we will eventually need to do a lookup into a generic instance, in
order to avoid regressing the tests.
This executes on a TODO in AddImportRef to add instructions to their own
block instead of the File block. This has an important consequence of
removing a pattern from InstBlockStack that added to blocks not
currently at the top, cleaning up an issue for ArrayStack. The delta
here is then mostly in different formatting of the import refs, a
consequence of the separation.
By adding an `ImportDecl` instruction, this creates something that can
be referenced through `ImportIRInst`.
packages/no_prelude/implicit_imports_entities.carbon is getting a test
of this (import_conflict and import_conflict_reverse).
Also re-packs ImportIR from 24 bytes to 16 on 64-bit, since I'm touching
everywhere that makes one anyways.
This refactors how the implicit import is handled in order to retain
more name scope information. As a consequence, private access control
works better between api files and implementation files. Note though
that this will also be essential for name poisoning between the API and
implementation, as discussed in #3763.
In implementing this, I ran into a couple issues with namespaces that I
think point to flaws in their handling. I've fixed some and added a TODO
for the biggest issue (in check.cpp line 281-288), which relates to the
handling of namespaces of direct imports which are first evaluated
indirectly.
In `ClassType`s and `InterfaceType`s, track a `GenericInstanceId` for
the instance rather than just the argument list.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Build a `Generic` object for generic functions. This object tracks the
generic parameters that are in scope for the generic entity. Eventually
it will track other information about the generic too.
Add basic SemIR formatting support for generic functions.
Name scopes store the names in their scope in a `DenseMap`. Several
places reasonably avoid depending on the iteration order by sorting the
names -- they're in the formatting code path where that's a solid
approach.
Unfortunately, when we're importing one scope into another, we also need
to walk the entire scope and do something for each name. =[ This doesn't
seem like a great place to sort things to stabilize them.
I've switched to a fairly simplistic solution of having a vector of name
entries that can be iterated stably, and a separate map for lookups. I
didn't use the set-of-indices trick here because it's not clear that's
the right trade-off for a scope: likely a lot of small scopes here with
relatively hot name lookups. And the key here isn't a large or
dynamically sized thing that we're canonicalizing, it's a `NameId`. That
made me lean towards duplicating the name in the hashtable for lookup
and the vector for iteration.
I thought about a fancy approach of sorting the hashtable keys by their
values (the indices), but that would still require a bit of copying and
more code.
I also thought a bit about other optimizations, but decided to leave a
comment for now -- it's not obvious to me exactly how hot this is and
whether it's better served by faster lookups, being more memory dense,
etc. And that might involve more of an SOA layout change or some other
approach. Rather than do that here, and especially before switching
hashtables, I stuck with a simple approach to address the ordering.
---------
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
Don't use the pretty-printed type name, because that's intended for
diagnostics, not for a theoretically machine-readable format like SemIR.
Types are always constants, so omit the leading `constant.` on the type
instruction name.
Don't format the *type of* the function `F` as `"F"`. Instead use
`"<type of F>"`.
Also improve instruction naming for function and generic class name
values: name the value after the function or generic class, and add a
`.type` suffix to the type.
Adds access to the name lookup table in name scopes. This is so that we
can quickly check access during name lookup without resolving the entity
itself. Does this for names in general, but does not implement handling
for entity-scoped names, only namespace-scoped names (where they're
essentially just not exported).
Excludes `private` names from exports. Although names should be
accessible to `impl` files, that's not implemented here because we'll
probably want to do it by directly copying name lookup tables.
This has is a nice-to-have for me. Frequently I want to run a specific
test, and end up digging through output to be able to copy-paste the run
line. This uses TIP lines to inject the command into the file when using
AUTOUPDATE.
Note, one of the reasons I want this is because "bazel test
//toolchain/testing:file_test --test_output=all" has been regularly
exceeding bazel's output limit for me (workaround is either opening the
output file or specifying an obscure output limit flag), making it a
little harder for me to get the commands. However, frequently I'm adding
a file and want to iterate on it, so that's really the use case I have
in mind here.
Parse the name of a declaration as a sequence of `NameQualifier`s --
which have a name, possibly parameters, and a trailing period --
followed by a name and possibly parameters. This prepares us for parsing
declarations of members of generic classes and similar cases, but
actually supporting such member redeclarations is left to a future
change.
We previously required functions to have parameters, but no longer do,
following the direction of #3848. Cases like namespaces that can't
actually have parameters are now diagnosed in check instead of in parse.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Modifies the core package and literal handling to use factory functions
for standard type literals.
Updates function/builtin/import.carbon to stop depending on the prelude,
since it would list all the impls in the core file. Updates
alias/builtins.carbon to be failing (the type values cannot be aliased).
Note, I assume this doesn't affect all the TODOs (like for i32.carbon),
but does cut some things down (and requires updating some tests that
have prelude name conflicts, but I think they were intended to be
updated this way).
Starts warning on duplicate "export name" because I'm updating name
lookup to make it work.
Need to think harder about how to handle cross-package "export import".
But adding some failing tests to sketch out what *should* work.
Change syntax for package declaration to put the `impl` keyword at the
start and remove the `api` keyword.
To support this, rearrange processing of package, library, and import
declarations to use the general modifier handling support in declaration
parsing rather than special-case logic.
There is an ambiguity in `impl package.Foo as Bar`, which we resolve by
treating `package` as an introducer after a modifier only if it's not
followed by `.`.
This adds a `BindExport` instruction in order to better track the
location of the `export` itself, but a `bind_name_id` is also added to
`ImportRef` so that we know quickly where to put it in name lookup.
Merging identical names is a TODO. I haven't quite decided how best to
achieve that, because I do think the BindExport should be what's
actually added to name lookup.
Also, I will probably add a mode to DeclNameStack that blocks
non-namespace scopes. This seems to already be an error, but the wrong
one (maybe due to lack of support for cross-file decl/def support).
This addresses the const reliance of ResolvePrevInstForMerge by checking
the imported instruction, testing with `alias` name conflicts. Given the
need to examine structure, the helper function feels like it now gets in
the way, so I'm just removing it.
---------
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
This was to track use of a declaration after import, prior to a
redeclaration. Per [discussion on
Discord](https://discord.com/channels/655572317891461132/1217182321933815820/1236016521059237962),
we likely don't need this check due to the change in behavior of
`extern`.
Rather than potentially getting one of many `extern` decls and depending
on it by accident, it is now planned to be _required_ to be imported,
and the library doing a non-`extern` decl must _know_ it's importing the
`extern` decl. The stricter requirement on the library means it now
seems more reasonable to use the `extern` decl.
So kind of rolling back #3831, though keeping `ImportIRInstId` (at least
for now) and keeping `Loaded`/`Unloaded` terminology (seems a nicer
fit).
This removes the builtin FunctionType, replacing it with a FunctionType
instruction. The constant for a FunctionDecl is now a StructValue with
type of FunctionType.
Note this means a function declaration produces _both_ a type, and a
value of the type. This has some consequences in terms of circularity,
and makes the importing of function declarations a little more complex.
It'll get particularly peculiar for imports because of the behavior of
the reference, but that's a known issue due to other things such as
`alias`. The impact will hopefully be contained to
ResolvePrevInstForMerge (and ImportRefs).
To note a small formatting change in diagnostics:
```
- // CHECK:STDERR: fail_member_lookup.carbon:[[@LINE+4]]:3: ERROR: Value of type `<associated <function> in Interface>` is not callable.
+ // CHECK:STDERR: fail_member_lookup.carbon:[[@LINE+4]]:3: ERROR: Value of type `<associated F in Interface>` is not callable.
- // CHECK:STDERR: fail_todo_facet_lookup.carbon:[[@LINE+4]]:3: ERROR: Value of type `<associated <function> in Interface>` is not callable.
+ // CHECK:STDERR: fail_todo_facet_lookup.carbon:[[@LINE+4]]:3: ERROR: Value of type `<associated F in Interface>` is not callable.
```
---------
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
Change the names for emitted globals for constants with storage to
include both the name of the constant and the name of the use.
This causes the instructions to also be named in SemIR and in LLVM IR
constants.
This could probably go further, but I'm just trying to get the ability
to run some significant tests without the prelude. This already requires
some migration of `i32` and `bool` to non-prelude-dependent types
(technically not at the moment, but I'm trying to stick with the
philosophical model of the prelude).
Note this undoes part of #3895 which had made all lex/parse tests depend
on the prelude -- I don't think that was a necessary change. Rather, it
seems better to isolate individual lex/parse tests from the prelude. I'd
been on the fence in that PR (it was fixing one of the issues that
contributed to wanting to not include the prelude), but now it feels
more consistent. The prelude could have a parse error and we shouldn't
break every parse test on that.
We don't need it any more, and removing it simplifies a few things:
- One fewer predefined `File` and reserved ID.
- We now have simply `Builtin` instructions for builtins, instead of
having an `ImportRef` that indirectly references a `Builtin`.
- `ConstantId`s now always refer directly to a local constant, instead
of sometimes referring to an `ImportRef` for a constant in the builtins
IR.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Use a level comparison during substitution to determine whether we're
substituting a particular binding. Evaluate symbolic bindings with the
same name and the same level to the same symbolic constant, for example
across redeclarations of a generic function.
In handle_class and handle_interface we assign TypeType, so is more
consistent. I think this had been missed because we haven't really been
using these declarations (historically, declarations didn't have a
type). It seems not to significantly affect output at present, although
I found this while trying to change merge behavior.
Adds support for unary `-` and binary `+`, `-`, `*`, `/` for floating
point types.
Real literals are now transformed to `llvm::APFloat`s during the check
phase into the `FloatLiteral` instruction.
This PR likely collides a bit with #3892 and might need to be updated
when that one is merged.
Factor out `SemIR::InstNamer` and also use it when lowering to LLVM IR.
Automatically name all instructions created with our `IRBuilder` based
on the name computed by the `InstNamer`, and likewise name basic blocks
using the label generated by the `InstNamer`.
Move some of the existing naming logic out from lower into `InstNamer`
so that it's also used in SemIR. In particular, we now name call
instructions after their callee, or after the builtin name for calls to
builtins.
Computing and adding these names isn't completely free. This instruction
naming is designed to be optional, so that we can turn it off for builds
where the LLVM IR will only be converted to assembly and won't be seen
by a human, but so far it's enabled unconditionally. We can tune that
later as needed.
Per offline discussion with chandlerc and jonmeow, use different
builtins for signed versus unsigned integer ops instead of looking at
the type. In this commit, the arithmetic builtins (add, sub, negate,
mul, div, mod) are split. I'll apply the same change to comparisons and
to right shift in separate PRs.
Use the complete location of the `as` conversion rather than the
location of the first operand, so diagnostics referring to the result
point at the whole thing.
Move completeness check to the point where the function is defined or
first called. This means we also defer deciding whether the function has
a return slot until that point. Instead of storing a return slot per
function, store the location of the return storage, which may or may not
be used, and compute and store a separate flag saying whether to use it
at the point of first use or definition.
This is the final piece in supporting simple `Make` functions in classes
as a replacement for constructors.
- Adds an empty prelude.carbon file
- Imports that file in any non-Core package file
- Adds --disable-prelude-import to avoid that
- Adds --exclude-dump-file-prefix to be able to hide files from dumping
- Used to hide core files (we can't do this by package name due to lex
dumps, for example)
- Restructures some tests to not rely on `i32`, particularly `alias`
tests (which rely on a name ref) and tests with no prelude.
I'm adding the framework for switching i32 to calling Int32 in the
prelude, but I'm running into a separate error actually switching over.
So that *mostly* works, but isn't quite ready for prime time. However,
maybe the current state of this PR is still useful to review since it
does a lot of the infrastructure work and adds the %Core everywhere?
Adds ImportIRId::ApiForImpl to reserve a specific slot for the `api`
import, so that the code can trivially determine whether an import is
from the same library. This is then used for merging function
declarations, because the rules for redeclarations in the same library
slightly differ as compared to other imports (note they're also not
identical to same-file rules).
The main thing this leaves from the recent #3762 is verifying that
entities forward declared in the `impl` file are also defined, but
that's not in-scope for merging; it's moreso post-checking validation.
Note, a lot of our `invalid <entity> ID` comments in ids.h were
incorrectly copy-pasted, so I've cut `<entity>`.
LookupNameInDecl is only called from DeclNameStack, but I'm adding
mark_imports_used there because it feels more consistent. Not sure if we
want a better API boundary. I admit I'm also suspicious of its call to
LookupInCurrentScope but maybe it's okay due to how imports work.
I was choosing to print multiple diagnostics when a declaration is
previously used _and_ doesn't match because I think the "previously
used" is more important, but the "doesn't match" may give an additional
hint about why it didn't work.
The merge.h utility function is because I think we can follow a similar
model for identifying errors with other declarations: classes,
interfaces, etc.
This doesn't significantly change logic, although I'm trying to add the
location to used state.
The issue I'm trying to address is how to identify a declaration as
"allowed to be redeclared". Consider:
```
library "a" api;
extern fn F();
```
```
library "b" api;
extern fn F();
```
```
library "c" api;
import library "a";
import library "b";
var x: auto = F();
fn F();
```
What currently happens is:
1. On import of "a", `F` becomes ImportRefUnused
2. On import of "b", `F` becomes ImportRefUsed in order to merge.
3. In "c", the call `F()` doesn't change the state.
4. In "c", the declaration `fn F();` needs some breadcrumb to understand
whether "F" has been referenced, as in step (3) here.
What I want to happen is:
1. On import of "a", `F` becomes ImportRefUnloaded
2. On import of "b", `F` becomes ImportRefLoaded in order to merge.
3. In "c", the call `F()` causes `F` to become ImportRefUsed
4. In "c", the declaration `fn F();` detects that `F` is already
ImportRefUsed, and can use the associated `used_id` for a diagnostic
about why redeclaring is invalid.
Note this PR isn't implementing (4). I'm focused on the refactoring to
add a new ImportRef state here.
Note we only identify conflicts between libraries in the current package
during import.
This restructures the BUILD because of dependency cycles between cpp
files... We're going to need context's name lookup to handle things such
as merging, merging requires function logic, function logic requires
context access. Per discussion, going with a single large cc_library for
now rather than trying to split out small libraries.
I'm envisioning the new merge.* as a hub for cross-declaration merge
logic. Note function.cpp is already pretty sizable, and I think it may
lean a little function-specific even if there are some utilities that
could be split out.
This replaces all invalid node IDs in import_ref.cpp with references to
the imported instruction.
This splits out ReplaceInstBeforeConstantUse into a separate function
when the LocationId is replaced, as for splicing. That's the less common
case, whereas others would need to provide the LocationId in order just
to not change the value.
Jon Ross-PerkinsandRichard Smith
Chandler CarruthandRichard Smith
Pablo Paglilla