Following up on discussion yesterday regarding this split.
Note, I'm expecting #3341 to do IdentifierId -> NameId in SemIR. It
might be worth adding NameId creation directly to StringStore if you're
content with this setup though.
Per the design, field access into a class value expression is a value
expression, even though we could produce an ephemeral reference
expression instead and avoid performing a value binding. This slightly
pessimizes class member access in some cases, but we should be able to
restore the old generated code by deferring actually performing the
value binding until a value expression is needed.
The value in the name lookup table is the class declaration. Map it to
the class type when it's found by lookup in an expression. This differs
from the behavior in a declaration name, where we want to find the class
declaration itself.
Advantages:
- Allows lexing/parsing in parallel, since they are modifying fully
separate ValueStores.
- Allows SemIR to reliably be stored hermetically.
Disadvantages:
- Creates overlapping storage of duplicate strings when multiple files
are compiled together.
- Prevents Ids from being uniquely compared cross-file.
Per discussion, the decision is that the advantages are more important.
The looser ownership remains because both SemIR checking and
metaprogramming may still generate things we would want to deduplicate.
It would be somewhat odd if TokenizedBuffer owned something that
checking modified.
If the initializing representation is the same as the value
representation, don't materialize a temporary and perform a value
binding. Instead, directly extract the value, using a new
`value_of_initializer` node.
This removes a lot of redundant `alloca`s from our generated LLVM IR.
I'm looking at this due to the conversation on #3341. Although
diagnostics aren't where they should be, I thought it may help to start
adding raw identifier support (which may also help show how I was
thinking about this).
Note regarding the TODO on how to form the token, `GetTokenText` returns
the `string_id`'s reference value for an `Identifier`. So to make
`GetTokenText` work in a way that returns `r#foo` for a raw identifier,
I think there are a few options:
1. Add additional data indicating the end of the identifier.
2. Add `RawIdentifier` as a token kind to indicate that it's raw and
should be prefixed with `r#` (but also giving later stages one more
token kind to handle)
3. Make the `string_id` correspond to `r#foo`, and have later stages add
`foo` to the strings table whenever `r#foo` is encountered (with map
lookups leading to deduplication).
4. Add `StringId::RawKeyword` special values for each keyword.
- This would mean `self` prints as `self`, `r#self` prints as `r#self`,
but `r#foo` is not a keyword so prints as `foo`.
- This means keywords would need to be listed in a place `StringId` can
depend on them, one way or the other (e.g., a `keywords.def` file in
`base/` should work).
5. Say that it _is_ an `Identifier`, and if it's a keyword spelling, it
must have been a raw identifier.
- Same limitation as above: This would mean `self` prints as `self`,
`r#self` prints as `r#self`, but `r#foo` is not a keyword so prints as
`foo`.
I'm hoping to resolve this issue separately though. :)
For now, we treat class types and `String` as non-copyable, because we
don't know how to emit SemIR to copy them yet. This will change as we
add support for copying those types when appropriate.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Adds a `BoundMethod` SemIR node to represent an `x.F` bound method, with
a new builtin type `BoundMethodType`. Reorganized conversion of call
expression arguments to also check and convert a `self` parameter in the
implicit parameters list.
In passing, improved diagnostics and error recovery for bad call
expressions. We now build a `call` node with the appropriate type and
value category, but with invalid arguments, if the argument conversion
failed, and diagnose calls to non-callable expressions.
`addr self` methods don't work properly yet; the `addr` is ignored for
now.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Provides an adapter for the llvm::yaml API because it otherwise needs a
bunch of const/non-const definitions, and the traits are difficult to
diagnose issues with. The current approach is pretty simple to use, even
if it's not super efficient (which, yaml output is more of a debugging
thing so I'm not really expecting it to be an issue).
Changes the format of yaml output to provide more index information,
just as reminders when seeing something like `node+0`. Note this would
create more churn in deltas if we were reliant on the output yaml in
tests, but we aren't so it should be okay.
Add support for member access into classes, for both non-instance
members and for fields.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Track the fields in a class, and generate a corresponding struct type as
the object representation for the class. For now, we always use a
pointer as the value representation for a class.
This replaces the use of `VarStorage` in this case.
Add an `UnboundFieldType` type as the type of a field, in cases where
it's referenced without an accompanying object.
Add a `BindName` node to describe the name binding performed for both
variables and fields so that we can handle them more uniformly.
This standardizes on having ValueStore and related structures provide
printing, removing the handlers in file.cpp.
The `[]` is provided for empty sequences versus if there was simply
nothing, in which case it would be a sequence when non-empty, and a null
value when empty. Consistently (and explicitly) providing sequences
feels easier to understand.
The changes to the output yaml are overall more terse. My hope is that
this is an improvement for most readers.
Also fixes printing of APInt, defaulting to unsigned for consistency
with Carbon's use.
Retain the `ClassDeclaration` node to represent a syntactic declaration
of a class (including possibly a declaration of a generic class), but
use a separate SemIR node to represent the class type itself. This
allows us to give the two separate treatment.
The `ClassDeclaration` is still entered into the name lookup table for
its enclosing scope, but when it is named in an expression, the class
type is produced instead. When the class declaration is named in a
declaration name, it can be used to define members of the class, but an
expression that resolves to the class type cannot be used to define
members of the class.
In order to distinguish these cases, use `Name` rather than
`NameExpression` for the left-hand side of a `QualifiedName` parse node.
This removes the only use of the `Expression` form of a declaration
name, so that is also removed.
In the future, `ClassType` will also be used to describe types such as
`Vector(T)`, for which there is no corresponding `ClassDeclaration`.
Building on #3311, change SemIR to use the SharedValueStore. Since this
removes hermeticity, raw output no longer prints ints, reals, and
strings. TokenizedBuffer accessors are modified to return IDs because
values are often passed through in semantics without needing to read
them.
I would've put SharedValueStores on Context, except for the
GetArrayBoundValue convenience method. I felt awkward removing that, so
it's on File, at least for now. That's then used by the formatter and
Lower too. The flipside of this is that TokenizedBuffer has a
SharedValueStores only for printing, so maybe that's similar enough to
what File is doing.
This doesn't start shifting other SemIR members to ValueStore, but that
seems like a next step.
This includes being able to define a class that was previously
forward-declared, and being able to define a member function out-of-line
that was previously declared inside a class.
No support for fields or methods yet, and a class definition doesn't yet
cause the class to be treated as a complete type.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jon Ross-Perkins <jperkins@google.com>
Incomplete types may be nested within other types; for example, a tuple
type might have an incomplete type as an element. Handle such cases by
walking through nested incomplete types when completing a type. This is
done non-recursively in case a very complex type is formed.
Types are generally no longer completed at the point where they're
formed. Instead, we attempt to complete a type when it is used in a
context that requires a complete type, and diagnose if the type cannot
be completed at that point. This will be necessary for classes, which
can become complete after their first use, and helps tease out bugs
where a type completeness check is missing.
Using the computed value representation, fix lowering of struct and
tuple values to use the value representation rather than the object
representation. Fixes an issue found in the review of #3257.
This currently causes us to compute value representations of all types
as they are created, which generates substantially more SemIR to
represent types. We can get some of that back by deferring computation
of the value representation until the type is required to be complete,
but some of the additional cost here will persist with this approach.
I also considered making the computation of the value representation
type be something that lives entirely within the lowering phase, but I
think that's not the right approach in the longer term, because the
value representation will be semantically visible and relevant once we
start allowing it to be customized.
We should consider moving the nodes that exist to compute canonical
non-local types, including value representations, out into a separate
global block. That will clean up the SemIR representation substantially,
and make the SemIR produced for a function not depend on which types we
happen to have encountered beforehand. But that's not being done in this
PR.
---------
Co-authored-by: Chandler Carruth <chandlerc@gmail.com>
Track the callee expression in full, instead of only tracking the
callee's FunctionId. This results in the `name_reference` denoting the
function actually being used.
Lowering now propagates a `llvm::Function*` as the value associated with
expressions of type `<function>`.
We were not creating `NameReference` node for names produced by member
access into a namespace, such as the second name in
`Namespace.Function`, which caused lowering of calls to such names to
fail. This is now fixed, but the resulting `NameReference` node only
refers to the name and the lookup result, not to the `Namespace.`
qualifier. We'll need to decide how to fit a third operand into that
node (perhaps we can stop storing the `name_id`, since it can be derived
from the lookup result) but for now the qualifier is not tracked.
Don't produce an error diagnostic if any of the information leading to
identifying that error is itself known to be affected by an
already-diagnosed error.
Bug found by fuzzing. Problem was untyped SemIR nodes had an invalid
type id, which was retrieved by `HandlePrefixOperator` and then passed
to `context.GetUnqualifiedType`, ultimately performing an invalid access
in `semantics_ir_->GetNode`.
We prefer to make a placeholder type for functions and namespaces to
remove the need for checking for the untyped case everywhere. Eventually
functions will have their own types, but this approach will be needed
for namespaces (and perhaps other non-first-class entities like unbound
methods and interface members) long term.
Co-authored-by: Richard Smith <richard@metafoo.co.uk>
Replace `SemIR::Node::GetAsFoo` and `SemIR::Node::Foo::Make` with
`SemIR::Foo` class that represents a particular kind of node, with named
fields.
Rename `SemIR::IntegerLiteral` and `SemIR::RealLiteral` to
`IntegerValue` / `RealValue` to better reflect their purpose and avoid a
name collision with the corresponding `SemIR` node kinds.
Remove `NodeKind::Invalid` and the `SemIR::Node` default constructor
entirely, as they were not used for anything.
A `let` declaration is represented by a `bind_name` node in SemIR:
```carbon-semir
%b: i32 = bind_name "b", %a
```
Because `Check` encounters the pattern before it sees the value, we
first create the `bind_name` node with an unset value and don't add it
to the block. Then, once we've seen and converted the initializer, we
update the `bind_name` to have the value and add it to the current
block, after the initializer code.
Also add `name_reference_untyped` for references to non-first-class
names without types, which currently covers namespaces and functions.
This improves the fidelity of the SemIR representation, and fixes some
issues where we would use the wrong location for nodes and diagnostics
downstream of a name reference.
We're still missing a representation for dotted name expressions, such
as `Namespace.Function`, and we don't use the `untyped` node as an
operand of any other node yet.
Trust semantics to have put them in the right places.
Many parts of lowering still need to be updated to use the value
representation chosen at the semantics layer, but this is an incremental
step towards that.
Combine the initialization, implicit conversion, and value category
conversion functions into a single function.
This substantially reduces the duplication between these steps, and
ensures that we support the same set of conversions in all these
contexts. This also fixes some issues where we would not use the proper
value representation for tuples and structs after performing implicit
conversions.
This makes the difference between errors and lower-level diagnostics
visible to users, and aligns the toolchain's behavior with the
expectations in `driver_fuzzer.cpp`.
Fix a bug where we would perform the computation of the return location
in SemIR after we have already used it in some cases, leading to
assertion failures during lowering. Instead, accumulate a sequence of
instructions to compute the return location in a temporary block, and
overwrite the return slot with those instructions when we perform
initialization.
StubReference is replaced by a more general SpliceBlock node, that takes
a code block and a result value, executes the instructions in the block,
and produces the result. This is used in the uncommon case where more
than one instruction is required to compute the return slot, which can
happen if we need to first emit a temporary and then index into it, or
if we need to perform multiple levels of indexing before we reach an
entity to initialize.
Factor out the common code to find the return slot for an initializing
expression, and use it to simplify the two different ways we finalize
initializers, as either initializing a temporary or initializing some
specific object.
This slightly changes the SemIR we create for function calls: instead of
rewriting the Call node to have a different destination and replacing
its temporary with a `no_op`, we now replace its temporary with a
`stub_reference` to the new destination. This results in the same amount
of SemIR being produced, but allows calls and other kinds of
initializers to be handled uniformly.
The speculative insertion of StubReferences after elements in an
argument list turned out to not be necessary, because we decided we want
to insert per-argument initialization steps after all arguments are
evaluated, rather than interleaving them. The StubReferences we insert
are causing some minor code complexity, so remove them.
We still create StubReferences when performing patch-ups of
already-emitted code, but we no longer ever need to look through them
when determining whether an initializer was a literal or when evaluating
a type expression.
This implements initializing expression semantics for structs and
tuples, following #2006 and discussions since.
Tuple and (and analogously, struct) literals are treated as having a
mixed expression category that is later resolved based on how the
literal is used, as either a tuple initializer or a tuple value, at
which point we create a `TupleInit` or `TupleValue` that represents the
formation of the tuple initializer or tuple value from the tuple
literal.
There's quite a lot of TODOs here, and the SemIR representation is still
not quite right, but this seems like a good place to checkpoint some
incremental progress.
- `Peek()` no longer returns a useful value, because we often don't
allocate a `NodeBlockId` until we finish building the block. Remove it
and update both its callers.
- Rename `PeekForAdd()` to `PeekOrAdd()` since it's no longer used to
get a block ID to add elements into.
- `PushForAdd()` was unused. Remove it.
- Add `NodeBlockStack::AddNode` to combine the operations of adding a
node and inserting it into a block.
Instead of modeling array initialization as a thin wrapper around tuple
initialization, handle it like a function call, with a return slot as
part of its input. This better matches how initialization via a call to
`ImplicitAs::Convert` will eventually work, and in particular lets us do
in-place initialization of arrays rather than always creating a
temporary.
`SemIR` now only stores complete blocks, and placeholders for blocks
where we need a block ID before we know the block contents.
This is a preparation step towards the new node block allocation design.